The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 1 April 1998Vol. 68 No. 4

of protectionism

p. 23 · Read in the full issue

Shipping

Cooks government accused

People are having to pay more for imported goods because there is only one freight provider in the country

By Florence Syme-Buchanan

Dawdling by the Cook Islands government to deregulate international shipping has earned it the unwelcome accusation of protec tionism and tacitly supporting a possi ble rip-off of consumers. The Cook Islands Chamber of Commerce believes people are paying up to SNZ2 million (SUSIm) more for imported goods than they should be. Chamber president Brett Porter says it’s because of the high freight component charged by sole service provider, Cook Islands National Line, a company in which the government has a 30 percent shareholding. Cook Islands National Line is the sole licensee for inter national shipping into the Cook Islands, a position the company holds by the grace of government and the minister of shipping.

The shipping portfolio was handed to relative cabinet newcomer Tupou Faireka in November last year by Prime Minister Sir Geoffrey Henry. After haggling with the government for over two years and get ting nowhere, the Chamber of Commerce Importers Council is taking a tougher stance. It wants the government to justify its stated shipping policy of just one licence to one service provider to operate into Rarotonga. . To date, there has been little action from the minister who says he is still wait ing for clarification on a number of details.

Among these is the assurance Faireka wants that any new service would not adversely affect Cook Islands National Line operations or arrangements between the shipping company and produce exporters. Faireka denies the government is protecting CINL The government obtained a 30 percent share in CINL over 10 years ago and sources reveal that the investment is yet to return one dollar. What that shareholding may cost the taxpayer is

not known, nor are details of any benefits.

George Ellis, a director and shareholder of the company argues that to deregulate international shipping would threaten the security of the current service - in shipping and aviation (both international and inter islands).

The Cook Islands experience over the last quarter of a century has proved con clusively that there is room for only one established operator in each market. Each sector has demonstrated the same lessons which the Chamber seems to ignore, says Ellis. Ellis says Pacific shipping is in a state of crisis with too many ships chasing too little cargo. He claims established regional operator, Pacific Forum Line, is one such company experiencing difficul ties. According to Ellis, desperate over seas shipowners are offering “good deals” in an effort to break into the Cook Islands market, but this would only be short term.

The shipping director went as far as to say the motives of the Chamber of Commerce are “suspicious” and the body’s “short-termism breathtaking.” The Chamber contends deregulation ultimately will mean cheaper freight rates to the whole of the Cook Islands and will be reflected in the cost of goods to all con sumers. Importers believe they are paying between 20 and 30 percent more than they should for freight. CINL charges more for freight to the Cook Islands than other countries it services.

To justify this, Ellis says the company has to go to other ports to try and find extra cargo to break even or survive and has to follow rates set by competition in order to get cargo. “We aren’t convinced of this the Cook Islands trade offers a lucrative add-on to regional carriers,” says Porter. In a position paper to Sir Geoffrey when he was shipping minister, the Chamber said the government should have a shipping

policy compatible with the government’s

economic reform policies.

“It should enable contestability, compe tition and the operation of natural market forces,” read the position paper. The Chamber feels the government’s delay in

deciding licensing policy has enabled a

monopoly to become deeply entrenched.

“The government’s actions (or lack of) in this matter give rise to suspicions that the monopoly is supported and may be permit ted to continue to exist for as long as the proprietors of the CINL wish it to do so.”

Shipping licences are issued at the discre tion of the minister and because of this, some business people say Sir Geoffrey’s and now Tupou Faireka’s failure to respond to the needs of importers is pro tectionism. Faireka says that’s “rubbish.”

He says he’s reluctant to issue any licences until he’s completely satisfied this would n’t jeopardise the service Cook Islands people presently have from CINL.

“If the monopoly is working for the Cook Islands, then we will leave it as it is.”

He said the Chamber of Commerce has asked the government to grant them a ship ping licence, which they would in turn give “to someone they are comfortable with.”

“Like hell we’re going to do this,” says Faireka. “What about our own entrepreneurial groups,” asked the Minister who says they have fears the Chamber could pass the licence on to a for eign operator that the government would not approve of.

Faireka says many business people are happy with existing shipping and have told him this. He would not name any, except to say they were from the southern outer island of Aitutaki.Two other companies have expressed interest in servicing the Cooks as an add-on to existing business in the region. One company, NZ Pacific Container Line, the biggest in the region, first applied in 1992 and again in 1995 to operate to the Cooks. A letter the compa ny sent to Trade and Transport Secretary Henry Puna in November 1996 indicated the possibility of a reduction in freight rates of between 20 and 30 percent.

“Importers have lost confidence in dealing with the secretary. The government’s

intransigence is totally unacceptable and at

odds with the stated reform policy which insists on open market delivery of services to the public.”

Porter says "we’ve come to the end of the line here, it’s time now that govern ment justifies their policy stance on ship

ping.” ■