The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 1 September 1969Vol. 40, No. 9

in Fiji—Lord Denning

pp. 50-51 · Read in the full issue

New sugar cane deal in Fiji—Lord Denning will arbitrate

Lord Denning, Britain’s lead

ing jurist, is arbitrating a new

sugar-cane contract in Fiji.

Sugar is Fiji’s biggest export and sellers of cane are some thousands of Indian and Fijian farmers. The buyers are the only millers of cane in Fiji—South Pacific Sugar Mills, a subsidiary of the Colonial Sugar Re fining Company.

The last time a contract was negotiated 10 years ago, politicians got strongly into the act and the results were extremely unhappy.

Farmers were persuaded not to cut their cane, and not to plant for the next season’s crop. There was a good deal of intimidation and burning of cane and of houses, and eventually the army and police had to be brought in to maintain order.

A Commission of Inquiry, headed by outstanding English lawyer and financial administrator, then Sir Malcolm Eve, and now Lord Silsoe, was appointed. It laid the blame for the beginning of the trouble pretty evenly on the British and Fiji Gov ernments, the CSR Company and the politicians—mainly Indian—who had made themselves spokesmen for the farmers, in order, the Commission said, to disrupt the industry to gain advantages for themselves.

Price controlled

The Eve Commission devised a system of independent direction of the whole sugar industry in Fiji and laid down a formula, based on costs of production and processing and marketing, and the price for which Fiji’s sugar is sold, either to Britain at a preferential price under the Commonwealth Sugar Agreement, or on the open market.

This was 10 years ago, and it has been a very peaceful 10 years in the sugar industry.

Now the time has come for a re vision of the contract, and the legis lation that followed the Commission’s report lays down a specific procedure for negotiations—replacing the lack of system that produced the chaos of 1959-60.

Millers’ and growers’ representa tives have ageed on major points but the crunch is—as one would ex pect—the price-fixing formula. How much of every dollar are the millers

to get, and how much is for the gjowers.

So the matter has been referred to arbitration and Lord Denning has agreed to be the arbitrator. He is Master of the Rolls in Britain and one of the world’s great jurists. He also reported on the Profumo affair some years ago.

He will be applying a very acute, judicial mind to the new sugar con tract, and will be helped by a former President of the Society of Accoun tants in the United Kingdom.

"An amusing story"

“What an amusing story” was Sydney lawyer, Mr. Francis Bren nan’s comment at Nadi Airport when he was asked on arrival about reports that South Pacific Sugar Mills Ltd. was contributing towards his fee in the arbitration on the new sugar con tract.

Mr. Brennan, Q.C., was briefed to represent the Alliance Cane Con tract Committee during the August arbitration hearing before Lord Denning.

He said he certainly would not have accepted the brief if there had been an indication that in some way or another there would be co-opera tion between the opposing parties.

He added that he had often re presented the Queensland Cane growers’ Council in opposition to the Colonial Sugar Refining Com pany and was no newcomer to the arena of sugar disputes.