Silence over Indonesian crude
p. 22 · Read in the full issue
SILENCE has fallen over the Fiji
government’s proposed monopoly
importation of Indonesian crude oil even though the October 6 deadline for worldwide refining tenders has long
passed. In September, Fiji’s Energy
Minister David Pickering and Trade Minister Berenado Vunibobo met their Indonesian counterparts in Jakarta to discuss buying 15,000 barrels a day of Indonesian crude oil.
The crude would be bought by a yetto-be-created monopoly company which would be 75 per cent Fijian-owned. In-
ternational petroleum companies could
tender to refine the crude and trans-ship
and retail the resulting petrol products
in Fiji and six other Pacific client nalions. At stake is a minimum of Fs2oo million a year in petroleum exports from Australia, New Zealand and Singapore through local subsidiaries of Shell, BP and Mobil.
In Jakarta, Pickering also said Fiji wanted to build a refinery of its own, possibly starting next year. Since those heady statements, there’s been no information from the Fiji Government despite strenuous enquiries up to the time of writing. Fiji government sources say no firm proposal has been tabled before Cabinet and there seems to be no idenlifiable official position on the Indonesian deal. This may hearten the deal’s
many critics. Pacific Island officials at the recent Forum Secretariat petroleum management committee meeting in Suva
privately expressed strong reservations
about the security of their future fuel
supplies under the monopoly regime.
The Indonesian crude which would be supplied to Fiji is of such a low-grade that it can be handled by only a couple of refineries, at most, on the Pacific Rim.
This leaves the supply vulnerable to re finery breakdowns, strikes and shipping delays. But the Indonesia deal is coming under most fire from island nations, oil industry experts and the Big Three petroleum multinationals over the Fiji Government’s claim that it will cut costs to the consumer.
The director of energy programmes at Hawaii’s East-West Centre, Fereidun Fesharaki, estimates the Indonesian deal will add at least 10 cents a litre to the retail price of petrol in Fiji alone. “If Fiji pays more then so will other countries in the region,” he said. Fesharaki doubts whether the Fiji Government can actual ly deliver on its pledge that the Indone sian contract will protect other Island clients from any price hikes resulting from the change in supplier.
Indonesia is expected to supply 15,000 barrels a day of crude: Fiji would use about 6000 barrels and other Pacific clients about 3000; leaving another 6000
barrels for sale in the open market. But Fesharaki says the 15,000 barrels a day are split equally between the worst grade of crude and an equally dubious conde nsate.
“This crude,” he says, “is so difficult to handle it’s not being refined anywhere in the Pacific Rim, it gives 70 per cent heavy fuel oil which has no use in Fiji and at the moment all of that crude is being burnt for electricity generation in Japan because the quality’s so poor.”
Fesharaki says the Indonesian crude will
require very sophisticated refining into
usable light petroleum products. “Pre
sumably they’ve got some refinery to
handle it, but the costs will be high and it’s not something you can take to just any refinery,” he said.
Retail petrol in Fiji is among the cheapest in the region with prices lower than those in New Zealand, Hawaii and Cali fornia. “The oil companies have been giving a very good price to their con sumers in Fiji, especially in the past three years, essentially because they’ve been able to use the trans-shipping facili ties,” says Fesharaki. “It will be hard to beat that especially with the unusual
crude supplied by Indonesia.”
Fesharaki says that despite Fiji’s
guarantee of price stability, it’s holding
neighbouring Pacific clients hostage to
the pattern of regional petroleum supply
and demand which depends on trans
shipment through Fiji. □
