The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 1 October 1977Vol. 48, No. 10

Rubbing salt into Banabans' wounds

p. 15 · Read in the full issue

The Banahans' cause suffered a stunning reverse when on July 29 in London the High Court ruled that they should be paid about $l4 000 as compensation for the effects of phosphate mining on Ocean Island.

Earlier, the British Phosphate Commissioners had offered about $1.5 million in an out-of-court settlement, but, in the words of Banaban spokesman in London, Tebuke Rotan, “we turned that offer down because we thought the High Court award would be better”.

Salt was rubbed into Banaban wounds by the court’s further decision that they would have to pay legal costs, estimated by Mr Rotan at about $460 000.

Mr Rotan said that in August he would go to Rabi Island, Fiji, where most of the 3 000 Banabans now live, to advise an appeal against the High Court decision.

Australia, Britain and New Zealand in May offered an ex-gratia payment of $lO million on condition that Banabans made no further claims “arising out of past events”.

In view of the proposed appeal by the Banabans over the recent High Court decision the offer from the three governments could now be in doubt.