The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 1 February 1966Vol. 37, No. 2

Future Of New Guinea

p. 94 · Read in the full issue

Yet Another View On The Future Of New Guinea

It is unfortunate that Sir A. Grenfell Price’s new book, The Challenge of New Guinea, has been published just now when there is a spate of New Guinea books in the shops.

IF published several years ago it may perhaps have served the purpose of drawing the threads of New Guinea’s development together in a way that had not been done for a decade. But published today, especially so close to Osmar White’s Parliament of a Thousand Tribes (reviewed in January, p. 59), The Challenge of New Guinea says little that is new, and does not fill any particular need. And it is an expensive book for only 180 pages.

Like White’s book, it is largely another compilation which might well have been shortened to a long article for the New Guinea quarterly.

Much of the information can be found in Gavin Souter’s New Guinea: The Last Unknown, a book on which Grenfell Price draws heavily (with generous acknowledgement).

The author says his book is designed “to examine in the light of history and present events, one of the few surviving examples of philanthropic colonialism, the Aus tralian occupation of Eastern New Guinea”. But it is not so much an examination as a competent, scholarly record of events. He describes New Guinea’s early colonisation and the colonials, the people themselves and the territory’s general development, particularly its development since the war.

He is very much a Government man. He believes that Hasluck’s post war policies have been right, except for the failing of over-centralisation, and that what Papua-New Guinea needs is time, and no interference from the troublemakers at the UN.

He says the Hasluck regime of 1951-63 was a “happy and progressive period” and there was a splendid growth of the “best type of philanthropic colonisation”. Wardship began to evolve into partnership, while Papuan political independence and management began to loom larger.

“The world should recognise,” says Grenfell Price, who is in his seven ties, “that the recent Australian development of the Territory has been so spectacular and philanthropic that the United Nations should seek to remedy the really grave harm they have done and trust the Aus

tralian-New Guinea partnership to proceed as both parties wish on the present co-operative lines.

“This will enable them to decide together the date for New Guinea independence, or, if the partners prefer, the admission of the territory to the Australian Commonwealth as a seventh state, snuggling its copra, cocoa, coffee, tea, timber and other tropical products in to the Australian economy.”

The one great weakness in the compilation is the lack of information on what the New Guineans them selves are thinking and doing, and perhaps this is due to the fact that this information can’t be got easily from books, or from the men in Canberra or Port Moresby.

While everybody would like to see things turn out as the Government and the author hope they will, it is probably attitudes within the ter ritory that will largely influence the results.—Sl.

(The Challenge Of New Guinea.

Angus and Robertson. 40/-).