The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 18 November 1946Vol. XVII, No. 4

The Scientific Angle on an Old Subject

pp. 18-72 · Read in the full issue

How "Cargo-Cult" Is Born

' T'HE semi-religious, native uprisings and disturbances which sometimes occur in Melanesia and go by such names as Cargo-cult, Vailalamadness, etc., have been reported frorn time to time in the “ PIM ” and various Islands residents have attempted to explain their cause and origin.

The following article is translated and condensed from a paper printed in the scientific magazine, “Nouvelle Revue deScience Missi was written by Dr. G. Hoeither, a scientist who did research work in New Guinea but Who now is established in Switzerland.

THE author of the article, Dr. C. Hoelt ker, distinguishes four different groups of religious fanatism: • Purely religious movements; e.g., mass-conversions, recollections, vil lage-retreats, etc. Similar move ments were often started among pagans who were untouched by any Christian influence. • Movements instigated by influential pagan natives (sorcerers, magicians, chiefs) in opposition to the imported Christian doctrine. These men call their clients together to fight a last desperate battle against the in trusion of Christianity. Naturally, their main objective is retention of prestige and income. • Purely political revolutions against the European race as such—e.g. the rebellion of police-boys in Astrolabe Bay about 1900; (three Europeans and one Chinese were killed); the revolution of native constables at Madang in 1942 (“PIM,” November, 1945); the “running amok” of police boys on the Sepik in April, 1942, when four white men and one Chi nese were killed. • Religious-political movements called religious madness, Cargo-cult, Chili asm, prophetism, Native King move ment, etc.

It is this last type of movement with which the author deals thoroughly, an alysing a great number of cases which happened during this last war. These Cargo-cult movements can be compared to that weed called horsetail (equise tum) which is almost impossible to eradicate. It is cursed by all farmers.

The roots penetrate the fertile soil to a depth of 15 feet and more.

Although such religious tendencies in primitives represent a general problem arising from any clash between European and native culture, even missionaries are still inclined to regard them when they manifest themselves as single an omalies. Often they are taken by sur prise and cannot apply any successful remedy. As a last resource an appeal is usually made to the government, and by the force of the law some of the re sponsible prophets are put in jail or sent into exile, and the movement seems to have come to an end.

However, this attitude paralyses the religious mania only for the time being, and, like the horse-tail weed, it will rise again. The best remedy is to check the movement right at its beginning, before great crowds and areas are affected.

THE main characteristics of this mania are the following; A great confusion of old paganism with newly impor ted, half-understood Christianity; over emphasised local patriotism; arrogant consciousness of being a distinct race; and aspiration to political and religious independence.

This movement is usually set going by the ecstatic dream of a native “prophet.”

He claims that some ancestors appeared to him and commanded him to announce the coming of the “golden age.” Every one is supposed to trust his promises as an essential condition of accumulating wealth without much effort. All natives, he promises, will be like their white masters, dressed in European clothes, living in concrete palaces, etc. . . . All white men, missionaries and government officials will be expelled.

Strong sexual tendencies, convulsions,

(Continued on page 70)

hallucinations and fits are the usual out ward signs of being obsessed by the spirit of an ancestor.

SUCH religious movements as these are by no means limited by time or loc ality. They have been observed at all times, in all parts of the world.

It is an undeniable fact, however, that they arise almost spontaneously when a pagan tribe gets its first contact with Christianity and accepts it in part only.

The immediate cause seldom can be traced, but occasionally the affected natives are at least influenced by extra ordinary events such as distress, famine, drought, epidemics, warfare, discontent

With prevailing conditions, animosity against the presence of Europeans, head tax collecting, any new doctrine of the Missions, earthquakes, etc. At all events, the wh , lteman is always to be blamed for mi sfortune or failure.

As a rule the prophets are extraordin arT personalities, strongly influenced by • se l xual Perversions, er Psyeho-Physiological conditions, fTIHE following Cargo-cult type move- X ments have been reported from Papua and New Guinea— in Papua: Milne Bay Prophetism 1893; Bagona-Cult in N and NE Divi sion (1911-21); German-Wislin Move ment Sabai, Torres Str. (1913-4)- Kava- Keva Movement, N Division (1914)- Taro-Cult of Orokaiva (1914)- Kekes’i Rites Movement, Manua, N Division

nQiQ/6ny a^a * a ' mac * ness ’ * n Division In New Guinea: Timo-Movement in Maladum, Huon Peninsula (1921); God- Father Movement, Suain, NE Coast (1930); Walman Movement, Aitape- Wewak (1931) Black King Movement, Wewak (1931); End-of-the-World Move ment, Pokwap, Markham Valley (1932- 4); Marafi Movement, Markham Valley (1933); Upinko Movement, Gitua, Huon Peninsula (1933); Fanatism in the Raw linson Range on Huon Peninsula (1933); Black King Movement, Ulingan, NE Coast (1935); End-of-the-World Move ment, Elap-Solop District, Huon P.; Chilasm Movement, Rai Coast (1935); Mambu Movement, Bogia-Banara Dis trict (1937-8).

The author does not claim that this list is complete, and additions would be welcomed. Movements in New Britain, Solomon Islands and Dutch New Guinea are not mentioned at all.

During the war years, Cargo-cult kept cropping up in different localities. There was, for example, the events at Inawaia, Gulf Division of Papua, in 1941; and in Lakekamu, Huon Peninsula, Malang, Sepik, etc., at later dates. There were also political-religious upheavals at Karkar Island and in the Aitape district, between 1941 and 1943.

ANEW factor in these movements during the war was the arrival of of the Japanese. With their innate shrewdness, the Japs were prepared to use the Movements to their advantage, and Jap newspapers even before the war were deeply interested in such religious movments.

When the Japanese arrived in New Guinea they identified themselves with the ancestors of the natives. Remarkable is the following address given by a Japanese officer at the occupation of Karkar Island by their forces: “Here I am, you have heard •of me often before,” he said. “Many times I tried to come to you, but I could not.

Now I am here. You see, we Nipponese soldiers do work. We are different from the Europeans. They let you work and do not pay you. Europeans never sit down with you at the same table—we do. Such is European; we are not such.

We do work—we ourselves —we do work hard. We can give you a good time soon.

You want a motor car, you’ll get it; you want a horse, a pinnace, a good house, a plane—you’ll get it. But you must work with us; help us down the European.

And then we’ll help you.”

The Japs distributed looted goods lav ishly and tried to get the co-operation of the natives in warfare. In a few cases they succeeded in confusing the natives by promises and threats, but the major ity remained faithful to their European masters.

European settlers in the Pacific should realise the grave problem involved in such new native movements. Although they cannot completely be eradicated, sufficient attention should be given to them to keep them under firm control.