Conspiracy Exposed in New Guinea Demand
pp. 35-36 · Read in the full issue
New Guinea Demand for Reform of Judicial System
(Contributed)
A CASE of great local and general in terest was heard recently in the Dis trict Court, Salamaua.
On June 5, a man whom we shall call “Smith,” a highly respected resident of Lae, was charged with a very serious offence against a small kanaka girl.
It proved to be an ingenious conspiracy by a native house-boy and three native accomplices (one a native police-ser geant) at the Salamaua Hotel. For a while, the case looked very black against Smith.
After three days and a half of careful cross-examination and argument by Mr.
V. A. Florance, of Wau, (counsel for the accused) the Police Prosecutor, Mr. W.
J. Livingstone, became convinced that Smith was the victim of a conspiracy and discussed the case with the District Officer, Mr. R. Melrose. During the week-end adjournment the “boys” were tricked into a full confession, and on Monday morning their confessions were read and the case against Smith was dismissed.
Mr. Downing, A.D.O., who heard the case, and Mr. Florance, both compli mented Mr. Livingstone on the fair manner in which he had conducted the prosecution, and assisted in unravelling
the tangled net in which Smith had been trapped.
The story is interesting from many points of view, and suggests the need for an overhaul of the judicial system in New Guinea.
Briefly, the facts are these: Smith is a successful recruiter and part of his policy is to be very generous to the native children and the old (lapun) men and women of the villages. Children constantly come to him to beg for “marks” (shillings) which he invariably gives. On Tuesday, 28th May, in the afternoon, he was resting in a small room on the beach, at the back of the Salamaua Hotel, when a “monkey” (small boy) and a piccanniny “mary,” about six years old, with one of the hotel boys, came to his room, woke him up, and asked for a mark to buy “kai-kai.” The hotel boy, Una, then went away.
Smith sat up on the side of the bed, and told them they must not come to his room, as plenty of boys about there were thieves, and if anything were stolen from his room he would wonder whether they (the children) had stolen it. He also reminded them that he had given the "monkey” some money that morning.
While talking to them in Pidgin he was playfully pulling the piccinniny’s hair and ears and patting her cheek. She tried to climb on to the bed, but he put her down, gave them a shilling, and sent them away. There were a lot of “boys” just outside the door, which was wide open, and the children were only in the room about two minutes.
In an adjoining room was Temba a “wash boy,” ironing clothes. He heard the voices and looked through a hole in the wall—saw everything that happened.
Temba had a “cross” against Smith—i.e., nursed a private grudge because Smith had frequently sworn at him for making
too much noise. So he invented a par ticularly revolting story, replete with disgusting details, and told it to a police boy. The ‘‘monkey” he schooled to cor roborate the tale, and a third boy, who had looked into Smith’s room when the children were there, also gave evidence of what he had seen—and added a lot more to fit in with Temba’s story.
Under cross-examination, the natives contradicted themselves and each other, without knowing it. Soon it became per fectly obvious that not one of their stories could possibly be correct. But they “stuck to their guns,” and the magis trate at mid-day on Saturday said it was a matter for the Supreme Court in Ra baul, 600 miles away, and that he had practically made up his mind to commit Smith for trial.
However, during the week-end, the “boys” admitted that the whole story was invented. They, no doubt, will be pun ished in due course, but that is poor con solation for Smith, for his distress of mind and loss of time and money. If the magistrate had committed him for trial it is unlikely that Smith would have been found guilty—although it is be lieved that certain men who were inno cent have been “framed” by natives and sent in gaol in New Guinea. To have cleared himself in Rabaul would have cost hundreds of pounds, and weeks away from his business. Also, Mr. Melrose Dr. Sinclair, Mr. Livingstone, and at least seven natives would have had to go to Rabaul, and a relief for Mr. Living stone sent to Salamaua.
Clearly, there should be some means of protecting white residents —every possible care is taken that a native has a fair trial. The law in this respect, as admin istered in New Guinea, is not what it might be. Some of the magistrates ap parently cannot bring themselves to be lieve that a kanaka will tell a lie —or, maybe, they have no confidence in their own discrimination, and will whenever possible commit for trial, and damn the expense.
The Criminal Code of Queensland has been adopted in the Territory and applies equally to white and black people. A
white witness is sworn in the usual manner, but a native is merely cautioned to tell the truth in these illuminating (but not very binding) words: — “Now you must talk true —das all — S’pose you gammon along court big fella trouble e come up behind (later)”; and he is asked “You savee?” He replies “Yessir,” and then proceeds with his evidence —or perjury.
But the worst feature of our system is that we do not have a Circuit Court.
Every indictable offence has to go to Rabaul. And why, in the name of jus tice and common sense, should this be?
Think of the waste of time and money when all witnesses have to go to Rabaul!
Magistrates are in nearly every case obliged to send indictable cases—however flimsy the evidence may be —to Rabaul.
Will the Administrator or one of the judges or the Crown Law Officer deign to answer the question “Why is there no Circuit Court in New Guinea?”
It has been promised for years; and now the Goldfields population is growing at a terrific rate, and the Morobe district is the money spinner for the Territory.
For many years Sir Hubert Murray himself went on circuit in Papua, for in that Territory they do try and keep up with the march of civilization.
The law is the embodiment Of everything that’s excellent, but why should they keep it all to them selves in Rabaul —at our expense?
Rev. Frank Lewis, chairman of the New Britain district of the Methodist Mission, left Sydney with his wife and young son by the Neptuna on June 29, after six months’ furlough in Australia. Mr. Lewis’ two elder sons are remaining in Aus tralia as boarding-students at Wesley College, Melbourne.

