Alarming new greenhouse research
p. 57 · Read in the full issue
NEW research by one of Australia’s leading marine biologists predicts coral reefs will be one of the first casualties of global warming and that their demise may be a matter of decades away.
For the Pacific, such an outcome would, obviously, be disas trous. Not only do coral reefs provide livelihood and export income for the hundreds of thousands of people involved in tourism and fishing but they also provide the main protection for coastal com munities against fierce waves thrown up by the increasing number of cyclones lashing the region.
The cause of the problem, it seems, is rising temperatures in tropical sea water. Coral is sensitive to sea temperature.
Over the past 100 years sea temperature has risen by one degree Celsius pushing coral to the very top in its thermal range.
Now sea temperature is rising even faster Eight of the hottest years on record have occurred in the last decade and in 1998, the hottest year, we saw an unprecedented world-wide mass coral
bleaching.
It is this sort of event that Professor Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Director of the Coral Reef Research Institute, at the University of Sydney, believes is threatening the future of the world’s reefs.
Bleaching occurs when microscopic plants, called zooxanthel lae, which live inside the cells of the coral (providing it with food), become damaged by heat and light. The coral expels the damaged zooxanthellae and usually dies a short time later from starvation.
While the fossil record suggests reefs can recover from bleach ing, it can take hundreds or even thousands of years to recover from one severe bleaching incident.
Recent mass bleaching events were first recorded in 1979. Since then entire reef systems have been killed by bleaching. During 1998 every region of the world experienced some severe coral
bleaching.
In his recently release research, which was commissioned by Greenpeace, Professor Hoegh-Guldberg set out to discover what sort of bleaching we might see in the next hundred years, if heat trapping greenhouse gas emissions, are not reduced.
His results were tested against four of the world’s leading cli mate change computer models and even conservative scientists are saying we should ignore them at our peril.
Hoegh-Guldberg found bleaching events are set to increase in frequency and intensity and that events like that of 1998 could become commonplace in 30 years. Every coral reef examined in Southeast Asia, the Pacific, Australia and the Caribbean showed
the same trend. In summary, he said: “the rapidity and extent of these projected changes, if realised, spells catastrophe for tropical marine ecosystems everywhere and suggests that unrestrained warming cannot occur without the complete loss of coral reefs on a global scale.”
Under current conditions, the southern and central portions of Australia’s Great Barrier Reef are likely to be severely affected by sea temperature rise in the next 20-40 years.
Greenpeace is using this evidence as its steps up its campaign to put a stop to a huge shale oil development that is in its pilot stages at Gladstone in Queensland, an area that suffered some of the worst coral bleaching in 1998.
Global warming, which causes coral bleaching and a host of other problems that threaten the very existence of island nations, is mainly caused by industrial pollutants, particularly those (green house) gases put off during the burning of fossil fuels.
Shale oil is notorious for being the dirtiest form of fossil fuel.
Over the next six years the Stuart shale oil development will receive around AUDS24O million in subsidies from the Howard government, without which many analysts suggest it would not be viable. This project is so big that Greenpeace estimates that by 2010, it could on its own, increase Australia’s greenhouse gas emis sions by up to 1.5 per cent on 1990 levels.
This does not seem to bother prime minister John Howard who bases his support for the project on the jobs it is likely to create.
What he ignores is the potential of the renewable energy indus try. Companies such as photovoltaic solar panel manufacturer, Pacific Solar, estimate that for SSBO million (a fraction of the investment involved in the Stuart shale oil project) Australia could lead the world in rooftop solar power, producing annual revenue of $1.16 billion by 2010 and creating 3,100 jobs.
The Pacific Islands, like the rest of the world, are relying on the Kyoto Protocol on climate change to begin the process of reducing greenhouse gas emissions.
Under that protocol the industrialised nations have pledged to reduce their emissions to 5.2 per cent below their 1990 levels by 2010, not nearly enough to stabilise concentrations of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere but, at least, a step in the right direction.
Now, it seems, even that small gain might be at risk.
Greenpeace’s latest analysis suggests that the so-called ‘loop holes’ in the Kyoto Protocol are so big that they will allow the industrialised nations to meet their commitments without taking any significant action to curb emissions.
This is being achieved by the failure to put adequate limits on emission credits (credits being given for some countervailing action, such as tree planting in another country) and on emissions trading (buying a quota of emissions from another country that is not going to use all its allocation).
The scale of possible emissions trading is only now being com ing clear. ■
Jemima Garrett
