NG’s “Ridiculous and Extravagant”
pp. 19-141 · Read in the full issue
tody Has a Good Word to Say For It NG’s “Ridiculous and Extravagant” live Labour Legislation Under Fire
From Judy Tudor, in Port Moresby On few occasions has the official majority of the Papua ew Guinea Legislative Council so ostensibly solicited the [official minority to save it from itself as during the debate i the five inter-related Native Labour Bills presented again the March meeting in Port Moresby.
j of the bills had their first iring at the last meeting in eptember, and debate had adjourned. ire followed a conference of aterested parties in January, this must have left no doubt e minds of the Administration tmental chiefs that the pro -5 had almost unbridgeable was thought that the bills ; then have not been pro d with, but for some reasons )wn this was not so; and the vere given the full treatment ilting in a four days’ spate of . that turned even the cynical )ers dizzy. m each bill suffered the same -all were adjourned until the meeting of Council, it people take it that this 5 that they will not be seen for at least a year, and then with considerable amendment, it unofficial members took Dr. other’s assertion, in his intro m to the Native Employment hat its fate would be decided e Council, as a polite fiction; onetheless they gave all their ies to the debate. 5, the first and probably most tant of the five bills, has been e stocks for five years, passed and forth between Port by and Canberra, and the ions as presented for Coun consideration were a monu d work, set out in 118 typed ap pages. covered everything from the vitamin intake of native • to a two-page description of nd of latrine required.
"'Major Social Tool"
ntroducing the bill, Dr. Gun iescribed it as a major social to cover both the primitive native and the skilled Papuan ig £3O per month. this, he remarked, was not n one document, t of the non-official members evidently prepared to regard •s the understatement of the i and most attacked the bill is ground.
In framing the bill, said Dr.
Gunther, the Administration held that its duty was to regulate the rate of native social change, to pre vent the unskilled breaking away from village life and creating a landless proletariat. At the same time the Administration had not
been unmindful of the ability of big industry to pay. The bill was designed to ensure that both the employee and employer carried out their obligations.
Mr. B. Fairfax Ross, by far the most vigorous speaker at this meet ing, was first at the attack.
The proposed legislation was, he declared, written round the wrong ideals and “sprinkled like hun dreds-and-thousands with the prin ciples of ILO’’.
At the same time, his impression was that it was out of date by about 20 years, and centred around life as it was then in old New Guinea, around Rabaul and the Bainings.
It did not take into consideration present working conditions in
Papua or in new New Guinea (the Hl ft hl made' the mistake of trying to cover in one piece of blanket legislation the primitive villager and the advanced native. There was nothing in it to improve on the old native labour ordinance; it was too complicated—particularly in its association with four other bills.
Greater Restrictions
Its restrictions on casual labour were greater than had existed in Papua for 30 years. It was fine to maintain village life, but if he were a native of the Delta swamps he wouldn’t want to be made to stay there if he could get work away where he could better himself.
Mr. Fairfax-Ross criticised the proposed restrictions on recruit ment, the sudden closing of areas to recruiting by local officials, the prohibition on payment of head money to new recruits, and par ticularly the new requirements for native accommodation.
He maintained that the dwellings provided should be in conformity with the earning capacity of the natives, and that it was useless to provide lined and ceilinged houses for natives just out of the bush who were just as likely to poke a hole
in the walls to store their posses sions there.
Other speakers called the pro posals confusing, cumbersome, too detailed. Mr. E. A. James said that the architect of the legislation had been so many years compiling it that he had become confused and that there were plenty of men of experience in the Territory who were capable of drawing up a satis factory code in months, not years. (Continued on page 139)
suggested that the Adminis ►n “wipe the whole lot”, make accessary amendments to the nt legislation and then, in due start out with a new concep
af employer/employee relations
jet right away from the native r conception that has been >asis of chinking for the last ars.
Native Support
i only people who came out ooted for the legislation were three native members —who probably carried away by the se of palatial residences, luru Rarua Rarua was a great nore pathetic than he realised he said that native children o school in Australia felt “dis ;ned and discontented” on return to see the conditions lich their parents lived and want to live in houses like Workers’ Compensation Bill, >n the agenda for debate and ■nment, was described by Mr.
James as an impracticable unworkable endeavour by ne to fall over backwards to racial discrimination —but in ng he had provided so many Ities and restrictions that it I’t work. remarkable piece of legisla ttempts to cover with one set ulations every worker in the )ry, from the highest paid to the lowest paid native tion labourer. 3r these proposals the maxi compensation payable to the ients of a member of the econd or third grade divisions Public Service was fixed at while in the case of a native tion worker the amount was £634/10 -.
Compensation Attacked
as not long before unofficial :rs were pointing out that the t compensation was far too id the lowest compensation o high—that in the case of ependents of a plantation 5r who was killed or died on ), £634 was a tremendous for- DUt of all proportion to the >f village native economy.
Fairfax-Ross, again leading tack, said that the bill pro a cover for contract planta r other native labour for 24 round the clock, day in and it, until the contract expired, ing like this had been at d in other countries. £634 proposed was equal to dinary labourer’s wages for years; while the compensa rhich would be available to /erage European would be
equal to only two years’ salary.
No reliable estimate of the cost of insuring workers had been forth coming from insurance under writers —estimates varied from £lO per annum to between £2 and £3, but he had worked out himself that for every 10/- it cost to insure a plantation worker, the cost of producing a ton of copra would rise by 1/3, (If insuring cost £2 per annum, copra production costs would rise by 5/-).
Beating the Air Late on Thursday night, March 6, the meeting ended, having beaten the air for four days and produced numerous machinery and corrective pieces of legislation—and one effective ordinance relating to the levying of export tax on copra.
The worth of the debate on the native bills has yet to be assessed.
In essence, it can probably be said that the bills themselves and the manner of dealing with them, re presents the conflict between Port Moresby and Canberra.
They were opposed by Mission and private enterprise members alike —in that they made ridiculous and extravagant demands on behalf of natives barely emerging from the primitive state; and did not take sufficiently into consideration the requirements of individual natives who had progressed much beyond that stage.



