The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 1 July 1954Vol. XXIV, No. 12

The Problems of Taxation

pp. 23-139 · Read in the full issue

and Loans Fiji A Change from Income to Customs Tax Possible

ANGLES of the Report of the Committee of Fiscal Review, involving changes in taxation which will affect most classes of the people, have been receiving a lot of public attention in Fiji.

The Report was before the Fiji Legislative Council, which sat in the latter part of June. The Governor said that some of the important recommendations in the report w r ere discussed at the Colonial Office when the Colonial Treasurer. visited London in May; the Report generally was approved; but further consultations between the Fiji Government and the Colonial Office were necessary before the most important recommendations can be accepted for implementation.

The most important changes proposed, in a general way, are the land tax and the transfer from direct taxation—that is, less emphasis on income tax and more on Customs tax. It is assumed that this is the outcome of the wellknown difficulties which the Goveminent of Fiji always has had in taxing the incomes of the Indians.

This has had the effect of throwing too large a proportion of the cost of government upon the non- Indian sections. More taxation of

imports and less of incomes will readjust this matter: but it may have other repercussions—so the Secretary of State for the Colonies (very wisely) will not permit any hasty decision.

From 1955 to 1960 (said the Gov ernor at the opening of the Legis lative Council) Fiji will need prob ably £8,000,000 for capital works, External loans may provide £4,000,000 —mainly for Suva’s new docks and water supply; the Colonial De velopment and Welfare Funds might provide £2,500,000 for reading and similar works; while the Colony it self might provide £1,650,000 for agriculture, housing, industry, and 80 forth,

Discussion of Fiji S Taxation

rrODiems

By “Tavite”

, , , T HE Flscal Review re P ort tabled A before the Colony’s Legislative Council has, as expected, aroused a lot of criticism from the various communities in Fiji, and there is bound to be pressure exerted on the Government so that each race, from a taxation point of view, will not be worse off than at present.

The Committee has made a genuine attempt to find a more equitable distribution of the tax ation burdens. But this is difficult, in view of the Colony’s peculiar problems and also because the Colony has outstripped itself in the field of direct taxation by the imposition of a scale of income tax, which, in the higher brackets and the company field, is comparable with that of more advanced countries, with far greater resources. A refer ence to the appendices in the report shows how lavish the Government has been in the past in following the Socialistic pattern set by the self-governing members of the Com monwealth, from whom the taxation machinery was largely borrowed.

The Committee’s attempt to get something in return for the Educa tion and Medical services is praise worthy—although it may cause some temporary hardship, particularly to the indigenous r N ace. At least it should adjust the disparity which existed when the Medical Service finances were heavily strained by the overwhelming and comparatively free use the hospitals and their pharmacies were put to by the Indians, who enjoyed this privilege as a surviving relic of the immigra tion days.

This further example that the Indian community does not cry “discrimination” when it benefits by it is mentioned here because there was no reference to the benefit by the Committee. It studiously but no doubt correctly omitted it. But the point has already been noted and publicised, as a reference to an article from Suva, under date May 12, will show.

To stifle the howl which would have gone up, and been heard per haps as far away as Delhi, the Com mittee took the next logical step of recommending that the Fijian, too, pay for his medical services.

If the recommendations on the Medical services are adopted—that is, everyone to pay—the Colony as a whole must benefit, because there should be a marked diminution in hospitalisation and drugs costs when the Indians have to pay. They in the past have been the biggest users of the free service.

How Does The Report

Affect The Investor?

ONE recommendation of the Com mittee should be of great in terest, now and in the future, to everyone connected with the Colony’s continued prosperity, ana especially to Australian investors, because the bulk of the capital in vested in the Colony is Australian.

This is the recommendation: 108. We consider It essential for com pany activity to be substantially developed In the direction of greater national pro ductivity (from which increases in the return of Government revenues can be expected to flow). This development is largely dependent upon the attraction or both men and capital (particularly risk

(Continued on Page 137)

capital) from overseas, and the rates of both personal and company tax play an important part in the matter. 114. In view of the close economic links between Fiji and Australia, we consider that the law in Fiji should be altered to provide for taxation of dividends in share holders’ hands. But it must be remem bered that this “double” taxation must affect the basic rate of company taxation.

For example, the basic company tax rate in Australia, where there is “double taxation” in this sense, is 6/- in the £; whereas in New Zealand, where dividends in the hands of the shareholder are non assessable for tax, it is up to 11/6 in the £. It is, after all, sensible and equitable that if the same money is taxed twice, it should be taxed on either occasion at the lower rate, than if it is taxed once only.

To quote and underline the first LI words, “in view of the close inks between Fiji and Australia” t may pay the Government to take mother look at this particular piece )f advice, because of the very strong md current agitations which re cently have been made in Australia :or the removal of taxation on iividends in shareholders’ hands.

With the return of the Menzies- Padden Government it is quite on ;he cards that this pernicious im iost will be removed. Even if it vere not, it is doubtful whether the suggestion that the income tax rate )e lowered {vide the last sentence n recommendation 114 quoted ibove) would provide any induce nent for investors —in the company leld, anyway—as it is thought that :he rate for this type of activity in ?iji is far too high. Thus, the de velopment of new industries prob ibly would be adversely affected by ;he adoption of a wartime practice vhich is suspect by investors. il THAT will happen to this report? ff The outcome will be awaited with interest. Our guess is that i lot of it will be implemented by ;he Government.

Apart from the Fijians themselves, ;he net result may be a slight rise n the cost of living, with the con aimer paying a little more for everything he buys or uses because >f the shift from direct to indirect & Biit it is doubtful, now, if the ;axpayer will benefit greatly fiom reduction in direct taxation, be 'ause the Government recently has considered the adoption of other re sorts which, if adopted will give ncrease in teachers’ and Civil ser /ants’ salaries. (See elsewhere^ How will it affect the Fmans.

Fhey more than anyone, IH ™rJe off financially. They could •Onsp the gap by working haider, r bv levyfng a tax on their own xportabTe y produce; or they could

toVeMf’ the

Fijians themselves will P™^ de best solution, possibly by a com

bination of courses. In spite of his reputation for taking things easy, the Fijian has sufficient worth-while ingredients in his splendid make up, given the chance, to solve this problem, too.

H Mr. David Wilson, former radio operator and sales manager in America, has been appointed South Pacific representative for United Air Lines, with offices in the APA Building, Martin Place, Sydney.

United is America’s oldest scheduled airline. It, operates a fleet of 174 four-engined and twin-e ngi n e d Mainliners, serving 79 cities and Hawaii.