The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 1 August 1952Vol. XXIII, No. 1

Future Of N. Guinea

pp. 37-39 · Read in the full issue

Col Murray And The

Some Quotations To The Point

Also see article 43 of this issue.

WHEN, in a statement he made in Brisbane soon after departing from Papua-New Guinea, Colonel J. K. Murray said that Australia might lose New Guinea as the Dutch lost Indonesia, by putting economic exploitation before native welfare, he stirred up against himself some well-informed criticism.

For example, here are some comments by Osmar White, of Melbourne Herald, probably the best-informed and soundest daily newspaper reporter who has recently visited the Territories. TlTis is from an article in Melbourne Herald on July 15:

I HAVE been to New Guinea three times since the war—the first time in the difficult days of re establishment, the last time when [the post-war order had been well established.

I On each occasion I left the Terri tory with the strong impression [that Colonel Murray’s administra tion had so far been unsuccessful and that it was, indeed, unlikely to succeed. This impression was based on a number of factors:— • Colonel Murray had antago nised a large proportion of Euro pean residents by an unnecessarily tactless insistence on a “natives

prst-last-and-all-the-time’’ policy.

• His refusal to accept advice from, or to support, Government officials of many years’ experience of the country, had greatly weakened the public service by forcing the retirement or resigna tion of many excellent men. • The efficiency and dicipline of ;he New Guinea administrative de partments were low. The men mder Colonel Murray all too often ’espected his sincerity but doubted lis capacity.

The only thing Colonel Murray leemed to do with force and con sistency was to expand native lealth and education services as ar as his budget allowed, encourage j he Missions, shield the natives as ar as possible from contact with ommercially - minded Europeans md prevent at all costs even a imited alienation of native lands.

Seen at a distance, this appeared '

idmirably humanitarian, but to

hose who knew the country and omething of its complex social and iconomic problems, it looked dan :erously unrealistic.

The Ward policy, as interpreted >y Colonel Murray, tended to lock ip all of Australian New Guinea as - “native reserve”—to make it an nthropological museum.

There are perhaps two million Latives in Australian New Guinea (pending from £5 to £7 million a ear on their health, education,

preservation, pacification, and ad ministration, how long will it take to raise them from a stone age culture to a modern political autonomy?

Colonel Murray would never admit that his ideal objective was impractical. He would never admit that the only way to give the peoples of New Guinea a chance to

survive in a fiercely pressing modem world was to develop the country’s economic resources vigorously and accord to its inhabitants a fair share of both responsibility and profit.

Colonel Murray would never admit that failure to do this would invite —or, indeed, provoke—a steady infiltration of surplus population from Asia and the eventual ab-

sorption or extinction of primitive peoples unable to compete with the newcomers.

It strikes most independent and informed observers of the New Guinea scene that if we are in danger of losing New Guinea, we will lose it far more quickly to the Javanese, Chinese, Japanese and Indians, who have need of its spaces and natural resources, than

to gallant, frizzy-haired autonc mists of a couple of centuries henc<

What Colonel Murray

Overlooked

Letter to the Editor COLONEL MURRAY, in his fare well speech, repeatedly re marked that the main reasot why the Dutch failed to hold Jav after the war, was that the socii and political advancement of i population had been lagging behin the country’s economic developmen For general information aboi pre-war conditions in Java, I wi quote a few lines from a repo:i by an extremely unwelcome visit* to Indonesia in the early stag* of the war:— “The Dutch are for the native They make them self-supporting, : that they lack nothing. With til help of their first-class scienttfl knowledge they have developed tH Netherlands East Indies, promote the people’s welfare, supplyin them with food, clothing an shelter. The result is that tl place may be called a paradis with a world record for density population.”

The author of this flattens comment was Lieut. - Gener Reikichi Tada, Imperial Japane Army, and his report was publish*, during the war in the Tokyo pap “Chugorong”.

According to this the averaj Indonesian cannot have been to

happy, even if he were aware of Lng a subject of a foreign atrolled government. If this was le, however, what could then :ount for those widespread riots ;er the war?

F’or this we have to consider the ects of 3 1 years of Japanese mpation, during which a hlishly ingenious type of propa ida was carried out. With typical ining it was directed not cso much irards the older generation, but inly to the youth of . the ages ween 10 and 20. Those people re flattered, enlisted in home irds (Heiho's), entrusted with irding European internment ups, taught how to torture, and octrinated with racial hatred, iously anti-Allies and anti oocratic. rnfortunately when “peace” broke , it was two months before any :>ps arrived on Java. Meantime, Japanese commander in Java, direct disobedience of his orders, r to it that arms and am nition were handed over to those onesian organisations which, ing the occupation, had been aborating with Japan. »ue to the late arrival of any ctive authority, anti-European s (in which the organisers had veniently forgotten about the eked” British and Americans, who were now concentrating the weakest European power, the oh) had broken out all over a. They were in full swing :n the first troops arrived, y a supreme irony of fate, anese-indoctrinated and trained tary organisations found them es suddenly acclaimed, the world as defenders of liberty and right to self-determination, have deliberately stressed the anese share in the Indonesian •lution, because Colonel Murray not mentioned it at all. Facts be ignored, but not done away i. Any picture of post-war flopment in Indonesia, which es out the Japanese share in

s incomplete, and misleading.

I am, etc.,

D. De Graaff.

t. of Agriculture, Moresby,

iss Beryl Ruth Oliver, daughter ■he Rector of Mursley, Bucks, [and, was married on June 28 tfr. Gordon James Slater, an ralian journalist now resident ondon. Mr. Slater is a son, by ormer marriage, of Mrs E ond, now of Sydney and lerly of Kokopo, New Guinea, re the war Gordon Slater was smber of the Burns Philp staff -abaul, and was one of the few escaped westward through the Britain jungles when the Japs Jed.