The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 21 March 1935Vol. V, No. 8

Circuit Courts In New

p. 50 · Read in the full issue

Guinea

Proposal Under Consideration

THE establishment of Circuit Courts in New Guinea has been urged on a number of occasions. Mr. W. E. Grose, M.L.C., brought the matter up for con sideration at the last meeting of the Legislative Council in Rabaul, in January.

The Crown Law Officer (Mr. Gerald Hogan) said that the introduction of the system of circuit courts advocated by Mr.

Grose was under consideration.

“In my opinion,” added Mr. Hogan, “no machinery for the administration of jus tice can be regarded as effective unless it takes justice to the people and admin isters it with dispatch, with independence, with certainty, and with skill. Judicial work should be performed by persons with adequate experience who are trained in the weighing of evidence and the re quirements of legal proof; and, if practic able, by such persons in the district in which a crime is committed and the wit nesses reside. Sittings of the Supreme Court held at frequent intervals at Dis trict Headquarters would remove some of the defects of the existing system.

“Because of general agreement with these views, the error is sometimes com mitted of assuming that the holding of sittings of the Supreme Court in Districts must of itself improve the administra tion of justice. Whilst I agree that it is very important that trials by the Supreme Court should be held in the District in which the crime was committed and the witnesses reside, yet I think all matters affecting the administration of justice in the Territory have to be carefully weighed when considering the introduction of the circuit system. One cannot ignore finan cial considerations, the staff available, and Territory conditions generally when con sidering any matter of administration.

“The question is, would the introduction of the circuit system under conditions existing in the Territory at present im prove the administration of justice in the Territory? The paramount consideration is the administration of justice to the prisoner.

“Even if the necessary transport were available and the circuit courts could be held at frequent intervals in each District, I doubt whether the advantages which would result from the introduction of the circuit court system outweigh the disad vantages under present Territory condi tions. The question of the introduction of the circuit court system is being carefully considered by the Administration at the present time. lam in favour of the in troduction of the system as soon as prac ticable.”