The news magazine of the South Pacific · since 1930

Pacific Islands Monthly, 26 August 1932Vol. III, No. 1

National Economics

p. 32 · Read in the full issue

In Tonga.

To the Editor.

Sir, —I have before me a copy of the June issue of “The Pacific Islands Monthly” and the contribution by your correspondent captioned, “Shall Mr. Cowley, of Tonga, Be Taken Seri ously,” calls for particular comment.

There is only one honest reply to this query, and the reply is—yes!

My first impression, after reading your cor respondent’s remarks, was one of depression— depression arising from the thought that such an excellent paper as “The Pacific Islands Monthly” should have been hoaxed by its cor respondent to publish such drivel.

Your correspondent’s remarks make an earnest man’s “blood boil.” The difference between the two contributors under discussion is that Mr.

Cowley’s article impresses one with its truthful air of righteous indignation in regard to the handling of the economic condition of Tonga; your correspondent’s article impresses one with the feeling that “a devil is in our midst.”

On the one hand we find a “gentleman” mak ing an earnest effort to assist this little Kingdom —on the other, a “person” deliberately abus ing the good work. Such a person is only fit for the good old tar and feathers!

As an instance of your correspondent’s un reliability: He ridicules Mr. Cowley’s state ment to the effect that three small shipments of kumaras glutted the New Zealand market.

Does your correspondent forget that it was he himself who stated that kumaras were one of Tonga’s “bow strings”? Does your correspond ent also fail to understand that Mr. Cowley is simply pointing out the foolishness of hoping for any economic uplift from such a source? I presume your correspondent possesses ordinary intellect, therefore his misrepresentation of Mr.

Cowley’s statement is the disgusting action of the knave. Mr. Cowley’s statement is not a bit humorous, although your correspondent pretends it is. After three shipments New Zealand buyers most definitely stated that they could not take further supplies for many, many months, as they had more than sufficient stocks.

Mention of your correspondent’s “bow strings” reminds one of another of the three he raved about. I refer now to bananas (copra was the remaining one). From the foregoing, it is ob vious how very weak the “kumara string” is.

The “banana string” is probably just as weak.

He stated last November that the industry would yield 20,000 cases per month. With a tremendous effort, the industry once yielded 9,000 odd. A few days ago it yielded 2,200 cases. Next month it will probably yield nil.

This is not because the banana season is finished —there are bananas pretty well all the year round—but, oh, sir, not 20,000 cases per month!

With reference to the third string—namely, copra. Well, we all know the pitiable state of the market. So much for your correspondents “three strings to the bow.”

Getting back to bananas, may I suggest that your correspondent make an endeavour to have certain of his literary sins pardoned by telling you the truth about this banana business?

Your correspondent’s final faux pas is his reference to “Charles and James of happy memory.” If the period during which these two kings reigned can be considered by your correspondent as one of “happy memory,” then may I suggest to him that if he intends to pursue his literary career of foolish endeavour he would lessen the likelihood of being classed absolutely hopeless (instead of merely hopeless) by refraining from historical references.

I am, etc.,

Observer.

Nukualofa, July 18.